Score: 0

"Sigh.."

submission: - -Car Wash- -

date: June 4, 2005

Seems like there's too much movies on Newgrounds that simply is a test in flash. They put in some figures they like and some music, test some stuff and just puts it out.
This has the be one of the greatest examples of this.

Score: 10

"Loved it."

submission: Mikey and Ruby

date: June 4, 2005

Totally.

Score: 9

"WTF in a good way"

submission: June Gloom Ep.4 !!!!

date: June 4, 2005

I am amused by the June Gloom series.
Nothing makes sense, but its all well.

Score: 1

"Most random nonsense ever"

submission: Not Another Clock Movie

date: June 4, 2005

I usually like random nonsense, but this was just nothing at all. Like watching an advert for nothing.

Score: 2

"This is incomplete work"

submission: Happy The Cat

date: June 4, 2005

Not only did the point of this suck, it was also too slow and bad paced.
Seemed like this was just a waste. If you put more into it it might have been good.
The animation is not the worst.

Score: 3

"Ugh"

submission: <<StripDown>>

date: June 3, 2005

I can't believe I actually played to level 7.
Well, ok. The idea is not the worst. The music though. And that awful woman. Oh well.

Score: 10

"Believe the hype"

submission: The Maxwell Edison Story

date: June 2, 2005

Yep, this pretty much deserves its place in the hall of fame here at newgrounds.
Top idea, top creativity, top animation and risky. Top notch.

Score: 5

"Erm..."

submission: Black Panther Café

date: May 27, 2005

Third one in a row I see by your works, and I have to admit I don't get it.
For this one I kind of hoped for some humor, but again.. Mostly violence. Violence supposed to be "cool", and way too slow. It could have been better if you the points were a bit sharper and to the point.

On the brighter hand your animation is really good.

Score: 6

"Uh-huh"

submission: Crucifer episode 01

date: May 27, 2005

Your style is very grim. Completely humorless. Grim and violent.
I don't know if I liked it. It seemed a bit pointless. A story about a little devil that bulids up to him killing a poor scared guy in the house, and oh, he does. And thats the whole point? Sheesh! And to angry metal music... Well..

You can animate still though. And the directing of it all is good.
But try something more original next time. And not sucha long selfindulgent intro.

Score: 7

"Good, but... hm."

submission: The Abyss : Komjo

date: May 27, 2005

This was actually very good in many ways. With your originality and style you should be able to do your own things though, thats why this movie puzzles me. I doubt you aked David Firth if he was okay with this.
In a way I kind of feel its his universe and he should therefore be the only one telling from it. No matter how good or interesting someone else might use it.
If David said he was okay with it, then sure.. but somehow I doubt that is the case here.

That said, it was still very good. A lot more silent and grim than the original SF by Firth, but still kind of keeping some of the weird atmosphere. And the story works too.. and I like the way you tell it. Still, it feels kind of like stealing.
But if you can animate that good, and you can come up with good ideas.. why not make your own thing then? I hate it when good talents waste their time on tributes! You don't need to!